Ye Ole Fashioned Ice Cream & Sandwich Cafe- Mt. Pleasant

Always consistent ice cream at all Ye Ole Fashioned locations! Large, delicious servings. Pictured is two scoops with caramel, fudge (very thick), whipped cream, and wet walnuts POURING over the edge of the double cup 😋 Not pictured is a small (more like a medium) birthday cake milkshake with sprinkles. Their birthday cake flavor has chunks of actually birthday cake in it!

I was absolutely blown away by the service and genuinely happy-to-help attitude I received from Lakota and Kiana tonight. I mentioned to Lakota that I have a food allergy and asked if she knew which flavors were safe. Without hesitation, she said she would go back and check every single flavor if she had to. That response was so refreshing, especially since questions like this are sometimes met with pushback or reluctance to check labels. I was also concerned about cross-contamination, and Lakota immediately went the extra mile. She changed her gloves and even grabbed a brand-new tub of the flavor I wanted from the back. That level of care goes far beyond just good service. It made me feel safe, respected, and not like I was being an inconvenience. While all of this was happening, Kiana

It’s my favorite place for ever, i have so much fun in this place and they wings it’s so goood. In the ice cream area those cashier is not so friendly but it’s fine i just came to this place because i love the vybes

Great spot to get something cold after a hot day. They had the usual flavors and some unique ones too. I regret not asking for a sample of the Coconut castaway, it looked really good. I did not take a picture of my White chocolate raspberry truffle only because I devoured it. My wife really enjoyed her Black raspberry chocolate chip and our daughter said that the Blackcherry was good too.

We took the kids and their friends here for ice cream on a Saturday evening. The shop is on the southbound side of 17 in Mt. Pleasant and is easy to see from the road, especially at night. The shop has two parts; a sandwich shop and an ice cream shop. The sandwich shop looks good but we didn't try it. There was a long line for ice cream and their process is that a single person takes the order for your whole group, so if you have a lot of people (we had 7) then it might take a while for that single person to serve you all especially if you have a complex order. The reason I mention this is that the next server will call the next group and then there are a bunch of people all jammed around the counter trying to see the ice cream and taste their options. It basically gets to be a mess