900º Pizza and Pasta

Our 3rd time ordering over 3 years. The first year, 2022, was great! The second year, 2023, was not great. The whole recipe was changed and more saucy than cheese. Our final year, October/November 2025 is pictured below. Burnt, dried up, hard and greasy. It went right into the trash after we tried one slice. There was one other pizza being baked so it wasn't like it was too busy to keep track of. The place was empty. Guess that should've been a red flag to begin with. Won't return.

Ordered a White Pizza, Stromboli, and mozzarella half-moon… $71 order. Obviously, the “white pizza” ordered was just a plain cheese burnt cracker style pizza that was absolutely horrible. No sauce, no arugula, and dry. Ordered through the “slice” app and customer service refunded the cost of the pizza. If I was competing as a business owner against Bronx House Pizza, the advantage they DID had was delivery… I would have refunded the pizza and rushed out the right pizza. This experience only taught me that it’s just better to plan your day and swing by a better pizza place in your way home. Very unfortunate.

God, I hate writing bad reviews. I ordered a white pizza for delivery (which was great to have as an option) but was delivered a somehow both burnt to a crisp and ice cold pizza. I tried to get over myself and took a bite- it was just a cracker with rubber cheese on it. It also was not as advertised, some of the ingredients were missing. I drove back up to the restaurant and showed it to them asking for a remake, which they were happy to do. They remade the pizza but this one was just as burnt with rubbery cheese, no sauce, no arugula. I should have asked for a refund, but did not. The entire pizza got thrown away.

Very Nice people! We stopped on from out of town thinking we were just going to buy cheap fast pizza. Let me tell you this was good. It’s different and it was nice having different taste! Very good and lots of toppings they weren’t cheap. Made sure we had everything we needed to eat on the go. We will be back

Stopped in on our way through town today. We arrived a minute after they opened and the gentleman up front was very friendly and fast with getting us our food. It’s a small and quaint place that reminded us of our hometown pizza place. We just wish our pizza back home tasted as good as the one we had here! Will definitely be stopping in again when we visit St. Augustine.