Barbiere's Italian Inn of South Milwaukee

Had a lovely time, I’m horrible at proper food pictures but it was simple and to the point with epic hometown service. The sangria (red) I ordered I sucked down two of them and I don’t even like wine they were so good! The garlic bread I got with cheese and it melted in my mouth and had the perfect “cheese pull”. Thankfully I also ordered one side of meatball with some sauce to top it off and I almost fell out of my seat it was so good. The person I was with ordered the 10in sausage onion and something else topping pizza and the thin crust was the only right kind of crispy. I wish I could remember the name of our server/bartender but she was nothing but amazing. Can’t wait to come again I really want to try the anti pasto salad

We had my son’s wedding reception here on 2/21/26. We can say enough about the service! The staff was exceptional and very accommodating! The pizzas were on point and refreshed regularly! Thank you all for making our event seamless!

I’ll Start off by saying they have the best garlic bread around. Front and staff (Lizzy I think) was less than pleasant. We walked in without a reservation expecting a wait, pleasantly surprised we only waited a minute or two. We were seated at the table directly next to the door that constantly opens and all 5 of us including 3 kids were cold. I asked nicely if we could wait for a table not near the door (that is the only table near the door) and it seemed like the largest inconvenience and was then told with an attitude sure it will be 45 mins at least. Parties coming in directly after that were not told 45mins therefore I know that was an in spite of comment. We left and are now sitting at DiCarlos for my first time and the staff here has been great!

The atmosphere is wonderful. Doesn't look like much when you walk in, but when you get to one of the dining rooms, it's warm and cozy. I don't typically care for the exposed HVAC system, but I do prefer it to covering what appears to be the original carved/molded ceiling work with a drop ceiling. Our server was lovely. She was friendly and personable. She was busy but it didn't appear to bother her. Would enjoy having her again. The food is very tasty. Mom ordered the Beef Ravioli with the Mushroom Meatless Sauce, I ordered the Cheese Ravioli with the Mushroom Meat Sauce, and because they don't serve appetizers, we both ordered the Side House Salad. The ravioli was not cooked long enough for my preference, though it's not an issue to deduct stars. I have a thing about texture in

Clean, quiet, and super duper good pizza. Sausage/pepperoni was excellent. Minestrone was decent but lacked something special for me. I don't add salt pepper to any of my meals generally but definitely would have enhanced flavor. The waitress was pleasant and attentive. We will definitely be back to South Milwaukee and can't wait for another pizza.