Candy's Pizza

Honest review based on my opinion. This was not it for me. Happy to see many ppl do like it but personally it was expensive for two small slices (7 bucks just one pepperoni and one plain), countertop was dirty, and was a little turned off to see the lady clean her hands on her shirt then grabbed my slices, heat them up, touched money, then went back to grab my slices out of the oven with her hands. As for the taste… super lite on the sauce, barely tasted it, pepperoni tasted like it was from those hormel bags you get at Walmart, small slices, but I gotta say it was well cooked with a nice crunch. So far best slice I’ve had in Sussex is Arturo’s in Lafayette and tj’s in wantage.

Between the genuine kindness and the superior quality of the ingredients in this pizza? This Pizzeria embarrasses most of the pizzeria within 100's of miles of it. This was the absolute last place I would expect to have some of the best pizza i've had in YEARS. It's also incredibly affordable. Have the meatball sub and a large plain cheese pie with my family.

Spent a long weekend with my boyfriend in PA yesterday and stopped at this spot on our way back to NJ. Best thin crust pizza I have had in awhile. Very nice little mom and pop joint

The pizza is one of the best I've ever had in NJ. Thin & crispy!

My wife and I are on the #eatjersey challenge to visit and have a meal in all 564 towns of NJ. We chose Candy's Pizza for Montague, our 161st town. We made it to the "top" of Jersey, both geographically and geologically! Montague is the northern most town at the top of the map of the state. It also has the highest point in the state in High Point State Park. Most other states have a sign that says "Last Exit in State" before you cross the border. Jersey has a sign that says "Last PIZZA in Jersey" before you cross the border, and Candy's Pizza is that place. We enjoyed a plain pie. Definitely a good place to get your Jersey pizza fix before headed to the pizza-less territories north of the state. :)