Cold Spring Harbor Cafe

Visited for the first time on Sunday when it wasn’t too busy. I purchased a cinnamon bun iced oat latte in a snowman to go cup. I asked for it to be less sweet since those types of drinks are usually way too sweet for my liking. It was delicious and just the right sweetness for me. I didn’t try any pastries or other food items, but I’d like to go back to try them. It was around $12 for the drink in the snowman cup, before tip. Seemed reasonable. I got it to go, but there are a few small tables inside to sit at. I would go back to try some other drinks, as well as the juice and smoothies.

I’m a sucker for a good marketing gimmick, and honestly, what screams fall more than sipping an iced pumpkin spice latte out of an actual pumpkin? It’s Instagram-perfect and definitely sets the vibe. That said, the price point stings a bit, $20 for the pumpkin version versus $6–8 for a regular coffee (which is about average). Would I buy the pumpkin coffee again? Probably not. But was it worth it for the seasonal aesthetic and cozy fall vibes? Absolutely. I didn’t get the chance to try the food, though everything I saw looked delicious. My favorite part was grabbing a seat by the window, the perfect spot for people-watching while enjoying a strong, good-quality coffee.

Quiet little coffee shop with a lot of seasonal special brews. Overall my coffee was particularly sweet and creamy, not a strong coffee flavor but it was a seasonal brew. Not many options available as far as food.

Good coffee! In a beautiful clean, locally owned Cafe in the middle of historic Cold Spring Harbor. We were lucky to have stumbled in on their 1st day, as the smell of fresh paint is still in the air. The two young women who own and operate the Cafe are super nice and patient, as the place is getting busy with local customers (and very kid friendly) I tried the Vermont Maple Latte and my daughter had a hot chocolate. Both very good and not overly sweet. But my favorite thing about it is that I'm sitting in a 200+ yr old building in a historically preserved town - one of the few left. Don't sleep on this place for a relaxing Sunday in one of the nicest towns on long Island.

i love this coffee shop! it’s been my go too for a few months now. When i don’t make my coffee at home i come here over starbucks any day. I can’t wait to come in the warmer months and enjoy the shops and villages around. Cinnamon toast crunch latte is 10/10!