Good Fellos

We came around 4:45 on Sunday and it was pretty empty. The prices are pretty high, but the portions make up for it. We ordered the calamari, my husband got the chicken Parmesan, and I got the scampi frito pico. The calamari and chicken Parmesan were good, but the scampi was wayyyy too sweet. I've never had a pasta dish that was that sweet. We might come back but I probably won't order the same dish again.

I visited The Good Fellos in Sackets Harbor, and it quickly became my favorite dining experience in town. I started with the Smoked Duck Wontons, and let me tell you—these were outstanding. Easily one of the best appetizers I’ve ever had anywhere. I honestly felt like I could’ve eaten my weight in them, they were that good! For my entrée, I ordered the Pollo alla Francese, and it was absolutely delicious—perfectly prepared, full of flavor, and wonderfully satisfying. I paired it with a glass of Hazlitt Red Cat, a semi-sweet red wine that complemented the dish beautifully. Between the incredible food, the warm atmosphere, and the stunning views of the harbor, this restaurant truly stands out. The Good Fellos was hands down my favorite place I tried while visiting Sackets Harbor. If I ever

The food was really good but more on the expensive side. A plate of bruschetta was $17 and that’s the cash price; costs more if you use card. Service was decent but kitchen messed up an order a bit. Make your own pizza is insane and $3 per topping even if it is just basil; came out to $28 for a personal pepperoni pizza with basil and spinach. Could be argued the food is worth the price. Was very filling and satisfied afterwards.

We were in search of a great Italian restaurant in the charming marina town of Sackets Harbor, and Good Fellos delivered on every level. From the moment we walked in during the early evening, the atmosphere was alive with energy. Patrons steadily filled the cozy indoor dining room and the scenic back deck, giving the whole place a warm, inviting buzz. The scent of the wood-fired pizza oven immediately pulled us in—it was fired up and ready, and so were we. The menu offered an enticing variety of options, whether you’re craving a classic Italian entrée or a perfectly crisped pizza. Every dish we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and clearly crafted with care. The staff were friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome from the start. Whether you’re visiting Sackets Harbor or lucky enough to

Excellent experience! The food was delicious, there was a wide selection of drink choices, and our bartender was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. This place comes highly recommended for a reason. Prices were a bit high but the quality of the overall experience (mostly) justifies it. Will certainly come back for date nights or special occasions.