Island Pie

Excellent pizza pies here! We did a quick to-go order using the website and it was super easy. I didn't see a way to build-your-own pizza but no matter, the sausage & shallots pizza was right up my alley (I added some jalapenos, see pic.) Mom loved her cheese & herbs pizza as well. They have wine and beer but the wine is by the bottle only. We got our pizzas to go then sat on one of the picnic benches outside. Great way to enjoy dinner during a beautiful evening, will definitely come again! Olympic Otter

Totally forgot to leave a review but this place is beyond exceptional, food was amazing, and the people that work here are amazing. Thank you island pie! We’ll definitely be back.

We had an absolutely fantastic meal there tonight. Both the Island salad and the sausage and shallots pie were unique and perfectly balanced in their flavors. All served in a very warm and inviting atmosphere with friendly service. Very glad we stopped in!

First the pros: The view from the patio is stellar. The roasted beet salad was the best thing we had there. The cons: To call what we experienced and saw service is a disservice to even a basic level of service. We ordered a beverage that was listed on the menu and our server had no idea it was on the menu. Twice food we did not order was delivered to our table that we did not order. Our first pizza was delivered 40 minutes before the second pizza was delivered. We had a half 4 cheese and half veggie. The 4 cheese was flavorful but the crust was overdone. The veggie had half cooked unseasoned veggies on it which made it hard to enjoy. Our second pizza was half the seasonal squash and half ham and pineapple. Both sides were under seasoned and therefore fell flat. Hopefully Vito Iacopel

Really, really good! We were staying in Deer Harbor Marina and based on other reviews, had low expectations. My husband ordered the lasagna and they brought it out before the pizza, so it was super hot and delicious. While waiting for the pizza, I regretted not getting the lasagna. When my sausage pizza arrived, it was steaming hot and the cheese was all stretchy when I pulled a slice out. My first taste of the cheese was buttery, rich, and slightly salty. I’m waxing poetic because I swear, this cheese was AMAZING. The crust was nice and crispy. I scraped my fork across the bottom and it made a lovely sound. I hate soggy crust. I briefly considered ordering a second lasagna and pizza for leftovers. I struggled to keep my husband off my leftovers at lunch the next day. The next time we