Michaela's Quality Bake Shop

Was headed to a birthday picnic and asked to pick up cake slices and cupcakes. Decided to stop at this local neighborhood business for the first time to support a local entrepreneur. The selection was great, and the server was very helpful. It was a great retail experience until I asked for plastic forks to take with me to the picnic. The forks were prominently displayed. The server gladly handed them to me, until the owner protested and insisted I did not need forks for the cupcakes, but only the slices of cake. After spending almost $40 on desserts, I was made to feel bad for requesting $.32 worth of plastic so that my friends could eat their cupcakes without getting icing all over their face. This is not a good recipe for repeat customers. While the cake and cupcakes were lovely

Beautiful cake for our daughter’s third birthday party and made her so happy. Also tasted delicious! Ordering was simple, and I love being able to support a neighborhood business. Highly recommend Michaela’s Bake Shop for anyone’s cake needs!

I had an amazing experience here!!! very friendly , cake was delicious! Fluffy & flavorful!!! cake looks exactly like the reference picture!! I would definitely recommend coming here for your custom cakes !

Little Chocolate pies and thalheimers cakes have always been my favorite. But just had a chocolate chip cookie and their CCC game has stepped up! They are amazing.

Placed an order for birthday cake, said we could pickup by 2pm on Saturday (today). Earlier today, they called to let us know that the cake is ready. When we arrived, she showed us the cake. The next day, we had the cake at/after church and most of it was eaten and was able to bring some home for us. Evidently, this birthday cake was a hit!