Sweet Jesus Niagara

I kept reading the hype about Sweet Jesus so on my last visit through Niagara Falls, the hubby and I decided to stop and get a sweet treat. Our consensus was that this place is definitely over-hyped. Neither of us was a fan of the ice cream here, and it's one of our favorite desserts. It has a weird consistency that doesn't even taste all that creamy, and the plain vanilla has zero flavor. The ice cream had a very light and fluffy texture that was unappealing, sort of like Cool Whip versus real whipped cream. I prefer my ice cream very thick and creamy. The flavor comes from the toppings, which were also a little bit boring. There are lots of weird sounding flavor combinations that they call "cone builds" that have sauces and toppings that are over the top, but we opted for a cone with c

Original menu! Best rage rocky road ice cream i ever had. Great quality, prices are decent and customer service was fantastic. Thank you Wellington & Gwendoline (hope im typing your name correctly). Definitely will come back!

I ordered ice cream and watched the girl making it—she looked completely uninterested and had no energy while preparing it. When she handed it over, it almost fell down. I’ve shared a picture as well. The environment was okay, but the service was honestly awful. The staff didn’t smile or make us feel welcome; it felt like they were doing us a favor by taking our order. They really need to work on their customer service and attitude.

A Bit of a Letdown This Time Around We’ve had Sweet Jesus before—mostly at mall locations—and we’ve usually really enjoyed it. But this time around on Clifton Hill, it just didn’t wow us. We went with milkshakes: I got the Birthday Cake, and my wife got the Mango. Hers was okay, but my Birthday Cake shake was super underwhelming. It was way too liquid-y, the cake bits had an odd texture, and the overall flavour was just bland. Normally Sweet Jesus is known for bold, indulgent treats, but this one fell flat. Also the cardboard straws are TERRIBLE. Broke a couple just trying to get them through the plastic lid. The location didn’t help either—Clifton Hill has gotten way more crowded than it used to be, and this spot became chaotic pretty fast. Might’ve just been an off visit, but based on

Be Dance in Niagara Falls in May of 2024. We had a long lunch break with several hours between dances and so we decided to walk down to Clifton Hill. I suggested the Hershey store. One of the moms (my new favourite) said "Let's go to Sweet Jesus." "What's Sweet Jesus?" "You've never heard of Sweet Jesus but you visit the Falls all the time?" "Yes. What is it?" "Ice cream. I'll show you." In my defense... Sweet Jesus is located inside the Canadian Gifts Marketplace on the north side of Clifton Hill just past Falls Ave. The Ice cream shop is IN the store, but it has a streetside window. On past visits we could order inside but in summer of 2025 they wanted us ordering at the street-side window and then picking up the ice cream inside the store. Sweet Jesus offers deluxe cones, sundaes, sh