Shelter Island Slice

Nothing beats their sicilian pizza. When i found out they moved here i was so happy. one of my favorite childhood memories was going into town for a slice. worth the 8 hour drive. <3 Thank you for bringing that taste and memory back i really enjoy it!

Got the chicken bacon ranch and added some marinara at the pizza makers suggestion... AMAZING. Super cool staff and the pizza is top notch. Thanks guys! 7/20/24 - I wanted to add a photo of the Sausage and Broccoli Rabe slice I had earlier this week. It is one of the single greatest things I've ever eaten in my life. Tremendous quality and the staff here are the absolute best! Thanks again fellas for always making it a 10/10

I Just moved here and HAD to try. But why not stop by on a Wednesday night in November? During Trivia night?! The pizza is perfect. Thin crust. Good options of toppings. And most importantly, the kinda place where you just feel like home. So, on a cold night in the offseason, this place was packed. That’s always a good sign… great vibes, great food.

Huge fan of the SI Slice! I had a couple slices after the Shelter Island Bucks game with a few of the players. This place does it right and the are proud sponsors of the SI Bucks. Large & delicious pizza slices you can choose from right at the front window when you walk in and served hot. The buffalo chicken (not very spicy) was good, the pepperoni (a beautiful NY slice), the chicken bacon ranch (a home run)! The pasta dishes look amazing! One of the players I was with ordered a dish and it smelled fantastic! Open seats inside and outside. TVs to watch current events and games as well.

We drove in 2 hours from Westchester because we heard the cook from Sag Harbor's La conca d'oro (Franco) moved here. He makes the most amazing dish - penne a la mimmo - with mushrooms, sausage, ground beef and pink marsala cream sauce. Omg. That's all I can say....eat with fresh garlic bread and split a house salad (they're giant).