Tuck Shop

This place is great. Delicious, homemade ice cream. Very nice staff. Lots of choices. Close to the Greenport ferry. Tell em Barsnobs sent ya!

This small ice cream shop possesses the finest ice cream, an epitome of culinary excellence and refined indulgence. With an unwavering commitment to quality, it employs the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients, crafting each batch with the utmost care and precision. The result is a rich, velvety texture and a taste that far surpasses that of commonplace, mass-produced varieties. The artisans, true connoisseurs of their craft, delight in concocting unique and innovative flavors that tantalize the palate with every refined scoop. The shop's intimate, charming ambiance and impeccable, personalized service further enhance the experience, rendering each visit an exquisite and memorable affair, befitting the most discerning of tastes.

An old fashioned ice cream store. We never go to Shelter Island w/o stopping in for a treat.

Fabulous ice cream, worth the long line. Got the ferry sundae which was superb. Only complaint is getting the unpleasant “stare” when they turn the screen for the tip on the credit card, not appropriate for a local ice cream place. They should just have a tip jar. Here’s your 20% (really?) but I won’t be back.

We stopped in and saw they serve multiple varieties of coffee. Being an ICE CREAM SHOP, we were looking for ICED coffee, we were told no, they don't have ice -_-. We then looked into a small cup of ice cream, $5 not bad, but when we went to pay, we were told $20 min for card. I will just say it's not worth meeting the min.