Wheatberry Bake Shop

This was my first time into the Wheatberry Bake Shop, and it certainly won’t be my last! The service was personable and outstanding! Everything was so delicious looking, that I didn’t know what to choose! I ended up going with an array of cupcakes and an eclair because it was recommended. I am currently having the eclair with my morning coffee, and the recommendation was warranted! (10/10) I can’t wait to try the cupcakes with my fiancé tonight! The only downfall of Wheatberry is that I live down the street and will be going too often!

My wife and I have been looking for a good bakery. Sick of Tops and Wegmans bakery. Due to traffic on 290, we took Harlem. We drove by Wheatberry and turned around and stopped in. What a awesome place. The baked goods looked fresh and homemade. They even have cupcakes which are hide to find. We tried their cookies, danish and eclairs. The Danish was great and fresh. The eclair was the best I ever had. Its my favorite baked product. The cookies were good. The cakes and bread looked good. Can't wait to try those.

Wheatberry makes the most delicious cakes, cupcakes, and cookies. They are my go-to for birthdays. Everyone who works there is kind, helpful, and patient. My son's birthday cupcakes were absolutely delicious. I can't say enough good things about Wheatberry!

We ordered my son’s first birthday cake from Wheatberry & it was phenomenal! The cake was so delicious & the customer service was amazing. Everyone was so friendly and really helped my vision come to life from start to finish!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ If there were an Olympic event for bread, Scott would be standing on the podium while the rest of the world argued in the parking lot. Scott is not just a baker. He’s not just a pastry wizard. He is the main character of Wheatberry Bake Shop and the undisputed World’s Greatest Bread Baker. Week after week, walking into that shop and seeing his smile while he hands over fresh-baked bread, cookies, and pastries is one of the highlights of our weekends. It’s not an errand. It’s an event. And here’s the real flex: We NEVER send thank-you cards to restaurants. Ever. But we actually sent one to Scott. That’s how much this place (and this person) means to us. Our “two-minute” conversations never feel rushed, never feel forced. Scott is warm, funny, welcoming, and just genuinely one